Skip to Recipe

Delightful Open-Face Plum Cake: A Simple Summer Baking Tradition

There’s something uniquely comforting and deeply satisfying about a cherished Sunday morning routine. For me, it often begins just before my partner, Ben, stirs awake. The quiet hours of dawn offer a perfect canvas for culinary creativity, a time when I can lose myself in the simple joy of baking. This delightful tradition, now firmly in its fourth week, has become a cornerstone of our weekends. Last Sunday, my heart was set on trying a marbled coffee cake recipe, inspired by Buttercake Bakery’s renowned moist butter bundt cake, which I’d spotted in the LA Times food section. The thought of finally putting my long-unused cathedral bundt pan to good use was truly exciting, promising a beautiful, fragrant treat to accompany our morning coffee.

However, today’s story isn’t about coffee cake; it’s about a sublime open-face plum cake that perfectly encapsulates the essence of summer. This particular recipe first caught my eye in a Martha Stewart Living issue last summer, and it had been lingering in the back of my mind ever since, a culinary whisper waiting for its moment. That moment arrived one glorious Saturday morning when Ben and I found ourselves wandering through the vibrant aisles of the City Heights farmers’ market in San Diego. The market was a sensory delight, brimming with the freshest seasonal produce, but one stall, in particular, called to me: overflowing baskets of ripe, jewel-toned plums, selling for an incredible $4 a basket, each containing at least twenty or so pieces of fruit. It was the perfect, undeniable reason to finally bake this cake.

The Irresistible Allure of Seasonal Plums

The farmers’ market experience itself was a treat. The crisp morning air, the cheerful chatter of vendors, the kaleidoscope of colors from fresh fruits and vegetables—it all contributed to a feeling of abundance and connection to our local food sources. Beyond the plums, we couldn’t resist picking up some perfectly ripe peaches, creamy avocados, and two succulent red snapper fillets, planning for a delicious evening meal. But as we headed home, it became clear that the plums were the true stars of our haul. These plums were simply exquisite: sweet, incredibly juicy, and bursting with flavor. I used about ten for the cake, carefully halving and pitting each one, but we still had plenty left over for Ben and me to snack on throughout the entire week. In fact, I savored the very last one just this morning, a sweet memory of our market adventure.

This easy plum cake recipe is credited to Bette Aaronson, a culinary enthusiast who has been making it for over three decades. After my first bite, I instantly understood its enduring appeal. It’s more than just a cake; it’s a testament to simplicity and timeless flavor. The preparation time is astonishingly short, taking only minutes to bring together. Despite its minimal effort, the result is nothing short of delectable—a tender, moist cake base crowned with sweet, caramelized plums. Its elegance is undeniable, making it suitable for both casual breakfasts and more formal dessert tables. And its versatility? Truly remarkable. While plums shine brightest here, the recipe explicitly notes that apricots, nectarines, and peaches make excellent substitutes. With that in mind, I confidently infer that other stone fruits like pluots, plumcots, and apriums would also be perfectly acceptable and equally delicious variations. I can’t believe Martha didn’t make that more explicit for us fruit aficionados!

Crafting the Perfect Plum Cake: Simplicity and Adaptability

For my household, I opted to halve the original recipe. A full 9-inch cake for just Ben and me seemed a tad excessive, though certainly not unwelcome! This scaled-down version yields a perfectly sized cake, ideal for a weekend treat without leading to too much indulgence or waste. For those who prefer a larger cake, perhaps for a gathering or simply because they can’t get enough, the original recipe is readily available online through the Martha Stewart Living website. Whether you choose the full or halved version, the core magic of this recipe remains: an uncomplicated process leading to a spectacularly flavorful dessert.

The beauty of an open-face fruit cake lies in its rustic charm and its celebration of fresh, seasonal produce. Unlike elaborate layered cakes, this style allows the natural beauty and flavor of the fruit to take center stage. The plums, halved and artfully arranged, not only provide a stunning visual appeal but also release their sweet juices and tartness directly into the cake as it bakes, creating a wonderfully moist texture and an irresistible aroma that fills the kitchen. The subtle spices and a dotting of butter over the fruit before baking add layers of warmth and richness, enhancing the plums’ natural sweetness without overpowering it.

Print