Discover the Magic of “Grilled” Romaine Caesar Salad: A Year-Round Delight

Prepare to transform your perception of salad with a dish that elevates humble Romaine lettuce into a culinary masterpiece. This isn’t just another side dish; it’s a vibrant, flavor-packed experience inspired by the genius of Susan Spungen, the celebrated food stylist, original Martha Stewart editor, and truly inventive cookie crafter. Her latest book, Open Kitchen: Inspired Food for Casual Gatherings, is a treasure trove of elegant yet simple recipes, all rooted in her philosophy of “get-ahead” and “stress-free” cooking. Each recipe thoughtfully includes “timing tips” with actionable steps that can be prepared in advance, making gourmet meals surprisingly accessible.

Upon first glance, one particular recipe, featuring grilled bitter greens, captured my attention. Susan’s enticing description—”A big platter of various halved and grilled heads of slightly bitter greens is a sight to behold and a cinch to prepare”—promised both visual appeal and effortless execution. Having made this dish numerous times now, I can attest that these words have never rung truer. Friends, this is a recipe that will change your salad game forever.

The Romaine Revolution: From Crisp to Charred Perfection

Have you ever considered grilling Romaine lettuce? For many, the idea of warm, charred lettuce might seem unconventional, yet it’s a technique that promises an explosion of flavor and texture. While countless recipes over the years have encouraged me to grill various greens, the opportunity often slipped by. But I’ve always been drawn to the concept, particularly my love for a perfectly charred vegetable.

What I discovered with Susan’s recipe, however, was an even greater revelation: achieving that delightful char without ever lighting a grill. Her brilliant note—”If it’s not grilling season, or you don’t have an easy-to-fire-up gas grill, you can do this under the broiler instead”—was a game-changer. This simple tip transformed a seasonal luxury into a year-round possibility, instantly making this dish a staple in my kitchen.

Under the high heat of the broiler, in an astonishing four minutes, halved heads of Romaine and, optionally, radicchio undergo a magical metamorphosis. Their edges crisp and caramelize, developing a rich, smoky sweetness. Their core warms through, softening slightly and releasing precious juices that bead on the surface, intensifying their natural flavor. This quick charring process imbues the lettuce with a depth and complexity that raw greens simply cannot offer.

The Heart of the Salad: An Umami-Rich Anchovy Dressing

Once out of the broiler, these beautifully charred greens are drenched in what can only be described as an “umami-bomb” dressing. Forgive my enthusiasm, but this isn’t your average Caesar. It’s a vibrant blend of finely minced anchovies, pungent garlic, delicate shallots, sharp mustard, briny capers, zesty lemon, and luxurious olive oil. This isn’t just a dressing; it’s a symphony of flavors and textures, with a delightful body that clings to every crevice of the broiled lettuce, ensuring a burst of flavor in every bite.

The anchovies, often a polarizing ingredient, are the secret weapon here. They don’t lend a fishy taste but rather melt into the dressing, contributing an incredible depth of savory, umami richness that elevates all the other ingredients. This dressing is so captivating, it stands shoulder-to-shoulder with the best Caesar dressings you’ve ever encountered, but with an added layer of complexity and texture that makes it utterly irresistible. It’s the perfect complement to the slightly bitter, wonderfully charred greens, creating a harmonious balance that will leave you craving more.

Why Broiled (or Grilled) Romaine Will Become Your New Culinary Obsession

As I savor each forkful of this extraordinary salad, I often find myself pondering: Is this truly Romaine? Romaine?! Perhaps unfairly, Romaine lettuce has often been relegated to a supporting role in my kitchen—a reliable staple for chopped summer salads, wraps, or sandwiches. It’s the background player, never the star.

But broiled (or grilled!) Romaine transforms this humble leaf into a showstopper. This isn’t just a meal; it’s an experience I would proudly serve to guests. In fact, this dish alone makes me want to host a dinner party, to build an entire menu around its stunning simplicity and profound flavor. It’s a testament to how a simple technique can elevate everyday ingredients to gourmet status.

True to Susan Spungen’s philosophy, this elegant dish is genuinely “a cinch to prepare.” Halving the heads of lettuce takes mere moments. While the dressing requires a bit more attention—finely mincing anchovies, garlic, and a shallot—it’s an overall ten-minute job that can easily be done ahead of time. For those who aren’t keen on chopping, a food processor can handle the mincing with ease, further streamlining your prep. The minimal effort yields maximum flavor, making it perfect for both busy weeknights and special occasions.

Elevating Your Charred Romaine Salad: Topping & Serving Ideas

While the charred romaine and umami dressing are undeniably the stars, the beauty of this salad lies in its versatility. In the summer, Susan suggests topping the grilled lettuces with fresh, chopped tomatoes, which sounds absolutely fabulous, adding a burst of sweet acidity. When tomatoes are out of season, I’ve experimented with several delicious alternatives that enhance the dish wonderfully.

For added texture and flavor, I often sprinkle olive oil-toasted breadcrumbs (pure heaven!) or toasted pepitas (deliciously nutty) over the top. To transform this vibrant side into a more substantial meal, soft-boiled eggs are an exceptional addition. Their creamy yolks and tender whites beautifully complement the rich flavors of the dressing, creating a perfectly balanced and satisfying dish that feels both comforting and sophisticated. Consider serving this gourmet salad with crusty bread to soak up any leftover dressing, or alongside a light protein for a complete, healthy meal. This recipe truly encourages creativity and adaptation, making it a favorite for all seasons.

Friends, I must confess, I have an incredibly hard time stopping once I start eating this salad. While I want to tell you that you can omit the anchovies if you’re not a fan, I truly believe it’s their magical presence that causes me to lose all control. Their savory depth is simply unparalleled. I wholeheartedly encourage you to give this one a go – you won’t regret it.

Essential Notes for a Perfect “Grilled” Romaine Caesar Salad:

• Parmesan Perfection! Did I neglect to mention the glorious dusting of thinly shaved Parmesan that melts and crisps under the broiler? This adds an incredible salty, nutty, and crispy layer to the charred lettuce that is absolutely divine. If you’re avoiding dairy, feel free to leave it out, but if not, it’s a non-negotiable step for maximum flavor.
• Lettuce Love! While the original recipe suggests dandelion greens, radicchio, or Treviso, don’t feel compelled to embark on a wild goose chase for specialty lettuces. Romaine lettuce alone delivers an outstanding result that is simply delicious. That said, if you happen to find other suggested chicories, they can certainly add a beautiful visual appeal and a pleasant bitterness that complements the dish well.
• Anchovy Advocacy! Of course, if you are strictly vegetarian, please omit the anchovies from the dressing. However, if you are someone who believes they dislike anchovies, I implore you to reconsider and give them a chance in this recipe. When finely minced and emulsified into the dressing, they magically “disappear,” imparting an incredible depth of savory, umami flavor without any discernible fishiness. They are truly the secret to this dressing’s irresistible complexity.

Here’s the play-by-play for this surprisingly simple yet utterly delicious dish: Gather your ingredients to begin this culinary adventure:

Start by crafting the irresistible dressing: Finely mince a fresh garlic clove and your chosen anchovies. I find mincing them together helps create a cohesive, flavorful paste.

Next, finely mince half a small shallot; you’ll need approximately one tablespoon for that perfect aromatic touch.

Combine the meticulously minced shallots, garlic, and anchovies with fresh lemon juice, Dijon mustard, finely chopped capers, and a generous pour of high-quality olive oil. Whisk until beautifully emulsified.

Prepare your lettuce by halving each head lengthwise, ensuring the core remains intact to hold the leaves together during cooking. Preheat your broiler to high heat, or your grill if it’s grilling season.

Line a baking sheet with foil for easy cleanup, then lightly oil it. Place the halved lettuce heads cut-side down on the prepared sheet. Drizzle with olive oil and season generously with salt and freshly ground black pepper.

Broil for a swift 2 minutes, maintaining a vigilant eye to prevent burning. The edges should begin to char beautifully.

Carefully flip the lettuce halves. Drizzle with a touch more olive oil and scatter thinly shaved Parmesan cheese generously over the top. Season again with a pinch of salt and pepper.

Return to the broiler for another 2 minutes, or until the cheese is bubbly and crisp, and the lettuce is charred to your desired preference. Keep a close watch as broilers can vary.

Once perfectly charred, transfer the warm, broiled lettuce heads to an elegant serving platter.

Generously spoon the exquisite dressing over the warm lettuce, allowing it to seep into the charred layers. Grate additional Parmesan cheese over the top for an extra flourish, if desired. Adjust seasoning with salt and pepper to taste.

For a heartier meal, crown your salad with perfectly soft-boiled eggs, their creamy yolks a delightful contrast to the charred greens and savory dressing.

This remarkable recipe, found in Susan Spungen’s Open Kitchen: Inspired Food for Casual Gatherings, truly exemplifies effortless elegance in cooking. So good, so simple, so unforgettable.

Print